kvalobs:kvoss:system:qc2:flag:regression

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision 		Previous revision
kvalobs:kvoss:system:qc2:flag:regression [2010-01-31 22:07:14]
paule 		kvalobs:kvoss:system:qc2:flag:regression [2022-05-31 09:29:32] (current)
Line 5: Line 5:
 ===== Strategy ===== ===== Strategy =====
  
-The kvalobs database data from 200908 (taken from the backups of histkvalobs) was analysed and all the combinations of controlinfo and useinfo were extracted (approximately 2275 in total). The controlinfo values were processed by setUseFlags(const kvControlInfo& cinfo) with the existing Qc2 logic turned on. The following table displays the original controlinfo and useinfo as well as the new useinfo generated by the Qc2 aware setUseFlags. The fourth column indicates if there is a change to the useinfo or not. In approximately 37% of cases the useinfo generated was the same. useinfo(13) and useinfo(14) were overwritten by XX in the table since this is the userid set by HQC.+The kvalobs database data from 200908 (taken from the backups of histkvalobs) was analysed and all the combinations of controlinfo and useinfo were extracted (approximately **2275** in total). The controlinfo values were processed by setUseFlags(const kvControlInfo& cinfo) with the existing Qc2 logic turned on. The following table displays the original controlinfo and useinfo as well as the new useinfo generated by the Qc2 aware setUseFlags. The fourth column indicates if there is a change to the useinfo or not. In approximately 37% of cases the useinfo generated was the same. useinfo(13) and useinfo(14) were overwritten by **XX** in the table since this is the userid set by HQC. AFter substituting XX it was found that the actual number of unique combination is **1076**.
  
 Questions: Questions:
   * Is th a valid regression test?   * Is th a valid regression test?
   * Are the differences a problem or not?   * Are the differences a problem or not?
 +  * i.e. are some differences only due to HQC activity and the Qc2 settings so far are ok?
 +  * can we commit the updated setUseFlags back into [[https://svn.met.no/viewvc/kvoss/kvalobs/trunk/src/lib/kvalobs/kvDataFlag.cc|kvDataFlag.cc]]?
  
-The results of the regression test:+The results of the regression test:{{kvalobs:kvoss:system:qc2:flag:useinfo-flag-test-200908.csv.gz|useinfo-flag-test-200908.csv.gz}}
  
 +And here is an extract comprising 100 results picked at **random** from the total set of results (note the table is too big to load as one into the Wiki):
  
 +^Oiginal Controlinfo  ^Original Useinfo  ^Useinfo with Qc2 On  ^Is there a change?^
 +|1110100000300011 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1000002000000600 |7138900400000XX1 |7038900000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1100000000000007 |3031900000000XX0 |3031900000000XX0 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1131000000000001 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1030002000000000 |7020200000000XX1 |7020200000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1500500000000007 |3131900400000XX2 |3031900000000XX2 |CHANGE | 
 +|1111100000000010 |7100000300000XX0 |5000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1211200000100000 |7010700000000XX2 |5010700000000XX2 |CHANGE | 
 +|1113000000000011 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1102400000000007 |3131900400000XX2 |1031900000000XX2 |CHANGE | 
 +|1113100000000000 |7120300400000XX1 |5020300000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1301100000000000 |7010100000000XX1 |5010100000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1030001000100007 |3891900000000XX1 |3891900000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1111200000000002 |3100000300000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1110000000300001 |3100000300000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1600600000100000 |7033700000000XX2 |7033700000000XX2 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1210100000100011 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1210000000000002 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1111300000000002 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1111200000100000 |7110700400000XX1 |5010700000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1510100000100022 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1000001000006006 |3895900000000XX0 |1895900000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1410100000100091 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1311000000000012 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1511000000100002 |3100000400000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1200100000000001 |3100000300000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1030003000000000 |7899200000000XX1 |7899200000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1211000000100000 |7010100000000XX1 |5010100000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1111100000100011 |3100000300000XX0 |1000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1511000000000012 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1211000000000012 |3100000400000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1010001000000000 |7890900000000XX0 |7894900000000XX0 |-4000000000 | 
 +|1030001000000005 |3892900000000XX1 |3892900000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1130000000300001 |3000000000000XX2 |3000000000000XX2 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1311100000000012 |3100000300000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1110200000100012 |3100000300000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1110100000000001 |3000000000000XX0 |3000000000000XX0 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1110000000100000 |7100000400000XX0 |7000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1200000000000002 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1201100000000000 |7010100000000XX1 |5010100000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1111000000100000 |7100000400000XX0 |5000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1010601000000007 |3891900000000XX1 |3891900000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1111200000100012 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1310100000100012 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1111001000000015 |3892900000000XX0 |1892900000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1111200000100002 |3100000300000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1102400000000000 |7020700000000XX2 |5020700000000XX2 |CHANGE | 
 +|1113000000000001 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1300100000000002 |3100000400000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1110300000100002 |3100000400000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1101000000000000 |7100000300000XX0 |5000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1100300000000001 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|110000200000000A |3138900400000XX0 |3038900000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1111100000000011 |3100000300000XX0 |1000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1131100000300011 |3000000000000XX2 |1000000000000XX2 |CHANGE | 
 +|1230000000000010 |7020200000000XX2 |7020200000000XX2 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1411100000000001 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1010100000000000 |7000000000000XX0 |7000000000000XX0 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1210000000100002 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|11110000000000B1 |3000000000000XX0 |1000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1200100000000002 |3100000400000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1300100000000000 |7010100000000XX1 |7010100000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1100100000000001 |3100000300000XX0 |3000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1103100000000001 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1102000000000100 |7010300000000XX1 |5010300000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1130000000000007 |3131900400000XX1 |3031900000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1210000000000012 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1310000000100002 |3100000400000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1130000000100007 |3131900300000XX1 |3031900000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1100000000001001 |3000000000000XX0 |1000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1411100000000021 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1210000000300001 |3000000000000XX2 |3000000000000XX2 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1110300000000002 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1600002000000000 |7138100400000XX1 |7038100000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1510000000000002 |3100000400000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1110000000300001 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1410100000000091 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1311000000100001 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1000600000000600 |7133700400000XX2 |7033700000000XX2 |CHANGE | 
 +|1210000000300001 |3000000000000XX2 |3000000000000XX2 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1112100000000011 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1311000000000012 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1113100000100000 |7020300000000XX1 |5020300000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1211000000000021 |3100000400000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1410000000000012 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1200101000000005 |3892900000000XX1 |3892900000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1100100000000001 |3000000000000XX0 |3000000000000XX0 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1311100000000012 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1600002000000007 |3131900400000XX1 |3031900000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1000601000000007 |3891900000000XX1 |3891900000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1111200000100002 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1311100000000012 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +|1210100000100002 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1600002000000007 |3031900000000XX1 |3031900000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1100000000002006 |3335900000000XX0 |1335900000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1001000000000000 |7100000400000XX0 |5000000000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1110200000100002 |3000000000000XX1 |3000000000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|0000002000000000 |9999900000000XX0 |9099900000000XX0 |CHANGE | 
 +|1110300000000000 |7010700000000XX1 |7010700000000XX1 |NO-CHANGE | 
 +|1411100000100022 |3000000000000XX1 |1000000000000XX1 |CHANGE | 
 +
 +<code>$ ~/DATA/FlagRegression$ awk 'BEGIN {srand()} {printf "%05.0f %s \n",rand()*99999, $0; }' wikitable.txt | sort -n | head -100 | sed 's/^[0-9]*//'</code>
 +
 +===== Initialise Useinfo =====
 +
 +This is the same as above except the useinfo is initialised with the original value (before it was not set), still see the problem with useinfo(7)!!!!
 +
 +^Oiginal Controlinfo^Original Useinfo^Useinfor with Qc2 On^Useinfo with Qc2 On and Useinfo no reset^Change?^
 +|1211100000100002|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1101200000000002|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1231100000100000|7120200400000XX2|5020200000000XX2|7020200000000XX2|CHANGE| 
 +|1111100000000000|7000000000000XX0|5000000000000XX0|7000000000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1100200000000012|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1113100000100001|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111200000000002|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1101100000000007|3031900000000XX0|1031900000000XX0|3031900000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1101200000000002|3100000300000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1140000000003000|7220400000000XX1|5220400000000XX1|7220400000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130000000300000|7120200400000XX2|7020200000000XX2|7020200000000XX2|CHANGE| 
 +|1100100000000001|3100000400000XX0|3000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|CHANGE| 
 +|1110300000100002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1201000000000002|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1111000000300001|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130100000100011|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|143000200010000A|3038900000000XX2|3038900000000XX2|3038900000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130000000000007|3131900300000XX1|3031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1110100000100011|3000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1500000000100002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1010601000000005|3892900000000XX1|3892900000000XX1|3892900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1311100000000002|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1211000000100001|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111200000100012|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1113000000000001|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1140000000006006|3335900000000XX1|1335900000000XX1|3335900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1010000000001000|7000000000000XX0|5000000000000XX0|7000000000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1110200000100000|7010700000000XX1|7010700000000XX1|7010700000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111400000000010|7020700000000XX1|5020700000000XX1|7020700000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111300000000002|3100000300000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|113030200000000A|3038900000000XX2|3038900000000XX2|3038900000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1100000000000400|7000000000000XX1|7033900000000XX1|7033900000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1202000000000001|3000000000000XX2|1000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1300100000000002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1113300000100000|7020700000000XX2|5020700000000XX2|7020700000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1110100000000001|3100000400000XX0|3000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|CHANGE| 
 +|1211100000000012|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1511000000000027|3031900000000XX1|1031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130000000100007|3131900300000XX1|3031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|0000003000000007|4899900000000XX0|4899900000000XX0|4899900000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1011100000000000|7100000400000XX0|5000000000000XX0|7000000000000XX0|CHANGE| 
 +|1200100000000002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1010001000000005|3892900000000XX0|3892900000000XX0|3892900000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1600600000000017|3031900000000XX2|3031900000000XX2|3031900000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1600002000000007|3031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1101100000000001|3100000400000XX0|1000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|CHANGE| 
 +|0000002000000000|9999900000000XX0|9099900000000XX0|9099900000000XX0|CHANGE| 
 +|1111500000100000|7020700000000XX1|5020700000000XX1|7020700000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1300000000000002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1330100000100012|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1211100000000011|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1501000000000000|7020100000000XX1|5020100000000XX1|7020100000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130100000300011|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1131000000000007|3031900000000XX1|1031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1000002000000600|7138900400000XX1|7038900000000XX1|7038900000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|160000200000000A|3038900000000XX1|3038900000000XX1|3038900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1511000000300001|3000000000000XX2|1000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1211100000000012|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1102100000000001|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130000000300001|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1101000000000007|3031900000000XX0|1031900000000XX0|3031900000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1411100000000022|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1101100000000001|3100000400000XX0|1000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|CHANGE| 
 +|1111300000000012|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111300000100002|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1211100000000011|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1510000000000002|3100000400000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1400000000000000|7120100300000XX1|7020100000000XX1|7020100000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1210100000100012|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1311100000000012|3100000300000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1600100000000011|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1200000000000002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1101200000000002|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1110100000000001|3000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1401100000000002|3100000300000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1130000000000017|3031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130000000300001|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|3000000000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111100000100011|3000000000000XX0|1000000000000XX0|3000000000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111200000100000|7110700400000XX1|5010700000000XX1|7010700000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1500000000000001|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1113100000000000|7120300400000XX1|5020300000000XX1|7020300000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1110100000100000|7000000000000XX0|7000000000000XX0|7000000000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130000000100000|7020200000000XX1|7020200000000XX1|7020200000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1402000000000000|7020300000000XX2|5020300000000XX2|7020300000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1102100000000007|3031900000000XX1|1031900000000XX1|3031900000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1500500000000007|3031900000000XX2|3031900000000XX2|3031900000000XX2|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1211100000100002|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1110200000100012|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1211000000000012|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1100000000000100|7100000400000XX0|7000000000000XX0|7000000000000XX0|CHANGE| 
 +|1510000000000002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1113000000100000|7020300000000XX1|5020300000000XX1|7020300000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1200100000000002|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1111000000000017|3031900000000XX0|1031900000000XX0|3031900000000XX0|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1130100000000001|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1110000000300001|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1002000000000001|3100000400000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|CHANGE| 
 +|1300100000000000|7010100000000XX1|7010100000000XX1|7010100000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1113100000100001|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
 +|1001200000000002|3000000000000XX1|1000000000000XX1|3000000000000XX1|NO-CHANGE| 
  
  • kvalobs/kvoss/system/qc2/flag/regression.1264975634.txt.gz
  • Last modified: 2022-05-31 09:23:18
  • (external edit)